Skip to content
Jodi Murphy Coaching
Approach Work with me About Questions
Book a call
Approach Work with me About Questions Book a call
Back to Blog
November 20, 2026

7 Executive Presence Mistakes That Quietly Undermine Your Influence at Work

J

Jodi Murphy

7 Executive Presence Mistakes That Quietly Undermine Your Influence at Work

You finish a meeting with a director two levels above you and replay it on the drive home. You said the right things. You had the data. And yet something felt off, and you cannot name it.

Here is what I have seen again and again in one-on-one coaching: the gap is almost never about intelligence or effort. It is about a handful of small habits that repeat every week, and that senior leaders read without ever telling you. These are the most common executive presence mistakes I work through with busy professionals and entrepreneurs, and none of them require a personality transplant to fix.

Below are seven of them. For each one I will show you what it looks like, why it costs you influence, and a specific correction you can try in the next five business days. Treat this as a diagnostic, not a verdict. Pick the two that make you wince a little, because that is usually where the leverage is.

Mistake 1: You present the work instead of the decision

This is the mistake I see most often from project managers, IT leaders, and technical professionals moving into senior roles. You walk into a room with a status update when the room is waiting for a recommendation.

Consider this example, which is a composite rather than a real client story. A manager brings a slide with twelve requirements and three open questions. The executive across the table has eight minutes and no patience for the journey. She asks, "So what do you want me to decide?" The manager, unprepared for that, walks the same twelve items again and leaves with a vague instruction to "keep going."

The work was fine. The framing was not. Senior leaders are not reviewing your effort. They are allocating attention, budget, and risk. Your job in the room is to make the choice obvious.

The correction: lead with the ask

Before any meeting with a senior stakeholder, write four lines and rehearse them until they are boring:

  1. The decision or support I need, in one sentence.
  2. The recommendation I am making.
  3. The single biggest risk if we do it, and how I am managing it.
  4. What happens if nothing is decided.

Then open with line one. Say it out loud before the slide deck. If you cannot write the ask in one sentence, you are not ready to be in the room yet, and that is useful information on its own.

Mistake 2: You over-explain to prove you are thorough

Over-explaining is a confidence problem wearing a competence costume. It sounds like two minutes of context before the actual point, or hedging every claim with three qualifiers.

I once worked with a director of operations who could not get through a sentence without adding, "but I could be wrong about that." She believed she was being collaborative. Her counterparts heard uncertainty, and they started routing decisions around her. That is the real cost: not that people think less of you, but that people stop bringing things to you.

If your point needs that much defending, the problem is usually not the point. It is that you have not decided what you actually think yet.

The correction: the answer, then the map

Practice a structure I call answer first, detail on request. Lead with the conclusion in one sentence, offer one supporting reason, and stop. Let silence do some of the work. If the room wants depth, they will ask, and you will now look like a person who can go deep without needing to prove it.

Try this on a low-stakes call first. One sentence answer. One sentence reason. Then pause and count to three in your head. Most of the time nobody fills it with a criticism. You just gave yourself room to breathe.

Mistake 3: You treat "presence" as a performance

Some leaders go the other direction. They adopt a delivery: a deeper voice, a firmer posture, a more formal vocabulary. It works for about a week, and then people can sense the effort.

A diverse group of professionals engaged in a business meeting in a modern office.

Presence is not a costume. It is the degree to which other people trust what you are predicting. That comes from steadiness, consistency, and reliability over time, not from a room voice. You cannot fake the pattern that produces it. You can only build it.

The correction: consistency over intensity

Pick three small behaviours and repeat them until they are automatic rather than performed:

  • You give a clear recommendation every time you are asked for an opinion.
  • You do what you say you will do on timelines you set, even the small ones.
  • You tell people early when something changes, before they have to chase you.

This is boring. It also works more reliably than any technique you will see on a stage. I would rather work with someone who is 3 percent steadier every month than someone who delivers a thrilling quarter and then disappears.

Mistake 4: You apologise for taking up space

"Sorry, quick question." "Just a thought." "I know you are busy, so I will keep this really short." These are small phrases with a real cost. Each one tells the room your input is an interruption rather than a contribution.

Working parents are especially prone to this, often without noticing. You arrive from a school run and the first thing out of your mouth is an apology for the fact that you exist. Executives do not take that as politeness. They usually take it as evidence that you do not see yourself as a peer.

The correction: strip the cover language

For one week, keep a tally of every "just," "quick," and "sorry" that opens a sentence. Do not try to fix them yet. Just count.

Then swap each one for a clean start. "I want to flag a risk on the migration." "I have a question about the timeline." "I disagree, and here is why." Same room, same input, different signal. It takes less than a week of tallying before most people hear the pattern in themselves.

What you sayWhat the room hearsSay instead
"Sorry, quick question."This person expects to be a nuisance."I have a question about X."
"I could be wrong, but..."No stated position to engage with."My read is X. Here is my evidence."
"Just following up on this."A reminder, not a request."I am checking whether we are still aligned on the date."
"Does that make sense?"Uncertainty about your own clarity."The decision I need today is X."
"Whatever works for everyone."No opinion, no ownership."I recommend option B, for these two reasons."

Mistake 5: You only show up when something is broken

If your only contact with senior stakeholders is escalation, risk, and bad news, you have trained the room to associate you with difficulty. You then become a person to be managed rather than invited.

Influence does not come from being the loudest in the crisis. It comes from the boring deposits you make outside one. A quick, useful note to a vice president about a competitor move you noticed. A heads up that a report will land a day late before anyone has to ask. A question in a meeting that shows you understand the wider business rather than only your own track.

The correction: one useful deposit every two weeks

Choose two people two levels above you and put a fifteen-minute block in your calendar every fortnight. Use it for exactly three things:

  1. Send a short, specific insight. Two or three sentences, no ask attached.
  2. Ask one question about their priorities, not yours.
  3. Close by noting something they can count on you for.

Fifteen minutes every two weeks is about thirty minutes a month. That is a small budget with a compounding return. The point is not to network at people. It is to become a known, predictable source of useful thinking before you need anything.

Mistake 6: You assume the C-suite knows your context

Technical leaders in particular assume that because the work is well documented, the value is obvious. It usually is not. Executives are working across many threads, and they are not reading your week in review with the attention you put into writing it.

This mistake hurts entrepreneurs working with executive clients too. You know the scenario you solved. Your client knows the outcome they paid for. If you never connect your work to the result in their language, you will stay a contractor rather than becoming a trusted adviser.

The correction: translate into business outcomes

Every update gets one line at the top: what changed, and what it means. Not the ticket reference. Not the technical detail. The commercial or operational consequence.

A diverse group of professionals engaging in a collaborative meeting in a modern office setting.

Compare "We completed the API migration on schedule" with "We cut transaction failures by moving the API, which should reduce the support backlog flagged at the last review." Same work, same truth, entirely different signal. One describes activity. The other describes leadership.

Mistake 7: You build your brand at random

Most of the leaders I work with can tell me what their team does. Far fewer can tell me, in one clean sentence, what they are known for and why anyone would seek them out. Without that sentence, your brand gets built by whoever happens to talk about you.

This matters most if you are building toward executive-level clients or a bigger seat at the table, because the decision makers are not reading your CV. They are trading on reputation inside a small network.

The correction: write your one-liner and test it

Fill in this sentence and keep it to fewer than twenty words: "I help [specific group] achieve [specific outcome] by [specific way of working]."

Then test it out loud on three people in an unfamiliar part of the business. If they nod and ask a follow-up question, it landed. If they smile politely and change the subject, the sentence is still too abstract. Rewrite it until it sounds like a real person who does a real thing.

The same discipline applies to your tools. If your brand lives in eleven platforms and four different intros, you are spending energy keeping those consistent instead of spending it on the work that builds trust. Simplify until the version of you in the room matches the version in writing.

A realistic week to start with

None of this requires a leave of absence or a personality overhaul. If you want a starting plan, here is one that fits around a full job and a school pickup, and it totals about three hours for the week.

  1. Forty-five minutes: Write the four-line ask structure for your next senior meeting, and rewrite your one-liner. Do both in one sitting.
  2. Thirty minutes: Tally your cover language for the week.
  3. Forty-five minutes: Build one update for a senior stakeholder using the what changed, what it means format.
  4. Thirty minutes: Send two short insight notes.
  5. Thirty minutes: Write your recommendation for the lowest-stakes decision you are sitting on this week.

Notice what is not in that list. No new courses. No big presentation to prepare. No waiting until you feel ready. Presence is built in the ordinary exchanges, and ordinary exchanges are already in your calendar. You are not adding something to your life. You are changing the quality of what is already there.

Why these corrections work

Each of the seven mistakes above has the same root cause. It is not a lack of skill, and it is not personality. It is a mismatch between what you are trying to communicate and how the room is reading it.

Senior stakeholders are scanning for three things in almost every interaction: can this person be trusted to decide without me, will they handle the bad news before it becomes a crisis, and do they understand the business rather than only their patch. That is it. When you lead with the ask, stay steady, strip the apology, and translate into outcomes, you answer all three without ever announcing yourself as a leader. That is exactly what confidence and clarity look like from the other side of the table.

I want to be direct about one thing. Reading a list like this and quietly agreeing with it changes nothing. You already suspected most of what I wrote. The work is the small, repeated correction in a live setting, and it is uncomfortable for the first few weeks, because you are removing habits that have been protecting you.

So pick one. Not seven. One. Start with whichever line in the table above made you flinch, and change only that for two weeks. Track what happens in the room. If your input starts getting picked up faster, or senior stakeholders start asking your opinion before you offer it, you will know it is working.

Then come back and choose the next one. That is how influence is built, in small drafts you never name but other people quietly notice.

Share

More articles

The Three-Line Visibility Plan: How Busy Professionals Build Influence at Work Without Adding Another Job

A practical framework for busy professionals who are doing good work that nobody upstairs can see. Three lines, twenty minutes a week, and a way to build influence at work that fits inside a real schedule.

Nov 20, 2026
The Three-Line Visibility Plan: How Busy Professionals Build Influence at Work Without Adding Another Job

How to Communicate With C-Suite Executives Without Shrinking in the Room

A practical guide for busy professionals who freeze up in front of senior leaders. Learn how to structure your message, prepare in 20 minutes, and hold your ground with confidence.

Nov 20, 2026
How to Communicate With C-Suite Executives Without Shrinking in the Room
Start Your Journey

Ready to get started?

Book a Free Call

Jodi Murphy Coaching

Executive coaching for busy professionals, working parents, and rising leaders.

Approach Work with me About Questions Contact

© 2026 Jodi Murphy Coaching

Client sign in
Powered by Coachful